Peres says UN Gaza report makes mockery of history 16Sep09 September 17, 2009

by Barak Ravid  -  Haaretz  -  16 September 2009

Peres and Goldstone copy

A damning United Nations report that accuses Israel of committing war crimes during its military offensive against Hamas in Gaza Strip “makes a mockery of history,” President Shimon Peres said Wednesday.

“The Goldstone Commission report is a mockery of history,” said Peres in reference to Richard Goldstone, the author of the report. “It fails to distinguish between the aggressor and a state exercising its right for self defense.”

Goldstone is a South African war crimes prosecutor who investigated Israeli and Palestinian conduct during Operation Cast Lead. Peres’ rebuke came a day after the prosecutor released his report.


Though the report accuses both Israel and Hamas of carrying out war crimes during the three-week campaign in Gaza, it focuses primarily on Israel’s actions during the hostilities.

The hostilities erupted on 27 December 2008 and lasted three weeks; Israel says 1,166 Palestinians were killed in the offensive, of whom the majority were militants. Human rights groups say, however, that approximately 1,400 Palestinians were killed, mostly civilians. Thirteen Israelis were killed during the fighting: ten soldiers and three civilians.

Israel launched the offensive in response to persistent Palestinian rocket fire against towns and communities in the western Negev.

In his statement, Peres added: “The report in practice grants legitimacy to terrorism, premeditated shooting and killing while ignoring the duty and the right of a state to defend itself, something which is explicitly stated in the UN charter.”

He blamed Hamas for launching the war, and said it also committed other “horrific crimes.”

“Hamas has employed terrorism for years against Israeli children,” he said. “It has detonated explosive devices in the heart of Israeli cities, harmed civilians, launched over 12,000 missiles and mortar shells aimed at innocent civilians with one clear goal in mind – to kill.”

Peres noted that Israel had evacuated its soldiers and citizens from Gaza, opened the Hamas-ruled territory’s crossings and aided in the rehabilitation of the Strip. After the Israeli evacuation in 2005, he said, Gaza was overrun by force by a “murderous, illegitimate terrorist organization,” which launched a coup against the Palestinian Authority.

“Instead of building Gaza and worrying about the welfare of its residents, Hamas built offensive tunnels against Israel and brutally used Palestinian children and civilians in order to conceal terrorists and hide weapons,” Peres said.

The president added that criticism against Israel’s actions fails to offer effective alternatives that can stifle rocket fire against the country’s outlying towns.

“It is a fact that the criticism leveled against Israel’s actions in response to Hezbollah fire from Lebanon and Hamas fire from Gaza and against the building of the separation fence did not stop the shooting in the south, the shooting in the north, and the planting of explosives in the center,” he said.

“IDF operations are what brought about economic prosperity in the West Bank, liberated Lebanon from the wrath of Hezbollah, and enabled Gaza residents to return to their daily routines.”

Barak: UN Gaza report is a ‘prize for terror’

The findings of the UN report constitute “a prize for terrorism,” aides to Defense Minister Ehud Barak told Israel Radio on Wednesday.

“The comparison between those who foment terrorism and its victims is unconscionable,” an Israeli defense official told Israel Radio.

The defense establishment is making efforts to extend legal aid to officers who may face indictment on war crimes charges abroad, Israel Radio reported.

Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon said the findings of the UN report were predetermined, Israel Radio reported on Wednesday.

Ayalon said that Israel’s cooperation with Goldstone would not have altered “one word” of the report. On the contrary, it would have “legitimized” the findings, Ayalon told Israel Radio.

Ayalon said the report “is a cynical attempt at role reversal in blaming Israel for war crimes instead of terrorist organizations.” He added that Israel would work to enlist the support of Western democracies in a campaign “to prevent turning international law into a circus.”

The deputy foreign minister, who is currently on a trip to Washington, told Israel Radio that the U.S. and the European Union both opposed the UN commission of inquiry.

Ayalon said he planned to meet Wednesday with U.S. ambassador to the UN Susan Rice to discuss ways to minimize the report’s damage to Israel before it is submitted to the Security Council for deliberations.


If you liked this article, please consider making a donation to Australians for Palestine by clicking on the PayPal link
Thank You.
Bookmark and Share

Add a Comment

required, use real name
required, will not be published
optional, your blog address